Running an online company store sounds like a dream, right? Your branded merch is just a click away, employees can easily order uniforms, and your marketing team doesn’t have to chase people down with sizing charts and spreadsheets.

‍

But like any good dream, it can turn into a bit of a mess if you don’t manage it carefully. From clunky platforms to confusing product options, a few avoidable mistakes can leave you with frustrated employees, unused inventory, and a lot of lost time.

‍

So let’s break it down. Whether you’re launching your first online company store or trying to level up your current one, here are the most common mistakes to avoid—and what to do instead.

‍

1. Forgetting to Define the Purpose of Your Store

An online company store can serve a lot of purposes: employee uniforms, customer giveaways, internal rewards, retail merch, or even franchise ordering. But if you don’t define its purpose from the start, things can get chaotic fast.

‍

Mistake: Trying to make one store do everything for everyone.
Solution: Choose a primary focus for your store—uniform fulfillment, internal swag, or external marketing—and build around that. You can always expand later.

‍

2. Too Many Product Options

It’s tempting to offer 47 styles of polos, 12 hat colors, and 9 different water bottles. More choices = better, right? Not always.

‍

Mistake: Overloading the store with too many similar products.
Solution: Curate your options. Focus on a tight selection of well-designed, high-quality products that represent your brand well. Your users will appreciate it, and you’ll reduce decision fatigue and returns.

‍

3. Not Customizing the User Experience

Your company store is an extension of your brand. If it looks like a stock Shopify template with zero personality, your employees won’t be impressed.

‍

Mistake: A bland, generic interface that doesn’t feel on-brand.
Solution: Customize the look and feel of your store. Use your logo, brand colors, tone of voice, and custom banners. Bonus points if the experience feels like a real shopping site (hello, modern fonts and mobile responsiveness).

‍

4. Skipping Sizing and Product Education

Let’s face it: sizing charts are never anyone’s favorite part of online shopping. But skipping them altogether? That’s a recipe for a swag disaster.

‍

Mistake: No sizing guidance or product info = frustrated users and tons of returns.
Solution: Add size charts, fit descriptions, and product videos or photos whenever possible. Even better, include notes like “runs small” or “athletic fit” to help people feel confident in their choice.

‍

5. Not Planning for Inventory (or Overplanning)

Inventory can be tricky. Too little stock means you’re constantly backordered. Too much means you’re swimming in extra hoodies from last spring’s company picnic.

‍

Mistake: Guessing on inventory without tracking usage or demand.
Solution: Use reporting tools built into your online company store to monitor what sells and what sits. Start small and scale smart. Some stores even offer print-on-demand or just-in-time fulfillment to reduce overhead.

‍

6. Ignoring Mobile Users

Think about it: your team is ordering swag while on the go, during a quick lunch break, or while scrolling in bed. If your store isn’t mobile-friendly, you’re losing users.

‍

Mistake: A clunky, desktop-only store that’s hard to navigate on phones.
Solution: Prioritize a mobile-first experience. Test your online company store on multiple devices to make sure buttons are tappable, checkout is smooth, and images look good at any size.

‍

7. Making the Checkout Process a Headache

No one wants to create a 14-character password and answer security questions just to order a polo.

‍

Mistake: A confusing, slow, or overly complicated checkout.
Solution: Keep it simple. Offer guest checkout if possible. Clearly show pricing, shipping, and delivery timelines. And don’t forget to auto-fill company codes or employee info to make the process smooth.

‍

8. Forgetting About Reporting and Analytics

If you’re not tracking what’s happening in your store, you’re flying blind. Who’s ordering? What’s most popular? What’s sitting untouched?

‍

Mistake: Not using data to drive decisions.
Solution: Set up reporting dashboards that give you real-time insights. Use this data to update your product mix, plan restocks, and adjust marketing strategies.

‍

9. Lack of Communication

You’d be surprised how many employees say, “Wait, we have a company store?” If you don’t market it, they won’t use it.

‍

Mistake: Launching the store and assuming people will find it.
Solution: Build a communication plan! Send out launch emails, share links on internal platforms, spotlight new products, and even create incentives (like free credits or contests). Keep the excitement going year-round.

‍

10. Not Partnering With the Right Provider

Maybe you tried to DIY your store. Or maybe you picked the cheapest provider. But managing an online company store takes real strategy, design, fulfillment, and support.

‍

Mistake: Working with a provider that doesn’t understand your needs.
Solution: Choose a partner that specializes in custom company stores. Look for one that offers everything from product sourcing and embroidery to fulfillment and customer service.

‍

(Psst… Flywheel Brands does all of that, by the way. Just saying.)

‍

Final Thoughts

Your online company store should make life easier, not harder. With the right setup, it becomes a powerful tool for boosting brand pride, simplifying swag logistics, and creating a consistent, on-brand experience for your entire organization.

‍

Avoiding these common mistakes is the first step to getting it right. Whether you’re just launching or looking to improve, keep the user experience at the heart of your strategy. Think like your employees. Shop like your customers. And keep things simple, branded, and fun.

‍

If you’re ready to build a smarter online company store—or if your current one could use a little polish—reach out to the team at Flywheel Brands. We help organizations turn their branded merch into a streamlined, stress-free experience. Let’s make your store a place people actually want to shop.

‍

Ready to ditch the mistakes and launch a better store?

Flywheel can help you launch a company store that delivers results and looks great doing it.

‍

‍Contact us today to get started!